Sensitivity of the grades

Grades recomputed from the per-curve errors in each model's score.toml. The tolerance factor scales both thresholds (RMS 0.015 and P95 0.03 of the axis box). The strict grade counts only the article and its supplement as published information (see Method).

Model grades

modelstrict gradetolerance x0.5tolerance x0.67tolerance x1.0tolerance x1.5tolerance x2.0
fornari_2019DCCCCC
hutchinson_2016DCCCCC
lindauer_2017DCCCCC
ouerdani_2015DCCB†‡B†‡B†‡
stein_2019DCCCCC
stroh_2019DCCCCC

Figure grades

modelfigurex0.5x0.67x1.0x1.5x2.0uses a value read from the figure
fornari_2019fig3CCB‡B‡B‡no
fornari_2019fig4CCCCCno
hutchinson_2016fig2CBBBBno
hutchinson_2016fig6CCCCCyes
lindauer_2017fig4CCCCCyes
ouerdani_2015fig4CCB†‡B†‡B†‡yes
stein_2019fig3CCCCCno
stroh_2019fig3CCCB‡B‡no
stroh_2019fig4CCCCCyes